# PHR interview scorecard

Candidate: ______  Interviewer: ______  Date: ______

| # | Question | Listen for | Score 1 to 4 |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | You are asked to investigate a complaint against a manager you know well outside work. What do you do? | Disclose the relationship and ask that someone else investigate. The appearance of a conflict matters as much as the reality, and careful notes do not remove it. Say nothing to the accused before the investigation starts. | |
| 2 | A manager wants to hire only men for a role because the work is physical. What do you tell him? | A belief about which sex is stronger is not a bona fide occupational qualification, and the BFOQ defense is narrow. A strong answer offers a job-related physical test applied to every applicant instead. | |
| 3 | Walk me through how you would fill a hard-to-fill role quickly and lawfully. | A clear job description and specification, the right sourcing channels, a structured interview asked the same way of every candidate, an offer, background checks done consistently, and onboarding. A strong answer names how they would measure the result. | |
| 4 | A required safety training session is scheduled for a Saturday for hourly staff. What do you check first? | Required training is hours worked for non-exempt staff, so it counts toward the 40-hour workweek and can create overtime. Pay it, record it, and check the schedule against each person's hours that week. | |
| 5 | We are adding an employer match to our 401(k). What do we need to get right on vesting? | ERISA's minimums for a defined contribution plan: no slower than a 3-year cliff or a graded schedule from 20% after 2 years to 100% after 6. Faster vesting is allowed. Then clear communication to employees. | |
| 6 | The controller wants to give every employee a gift card at year end. How should payroll treat it? | Gift cards are cash equivalents and taxable wages whatever the amount. The de minimis exclusion covers small non-cash items, not cards. A strong answer suggests a non-cash alternative if the aim is a tax-free thank-you. | |
| 7 | A supervisor rated an order picker "exceeds expectations" after a strong six weeks that followed months of missed targets. What do you do? | Recency error. Rate the whole period against the standard, using the supervisor's own notes, with rater training and calibration so the next cycle is fairer. | |
| 8 | Engagement survey scores dropped in one department. What do you do next? | Share the results with the people who took part, find out why through focus groups or interviews, agree an action plan with the manager, and measure again. A strong answer protects anonymity throughout. | |
| 9 | An employee reports sexual comments by her manager and asks you to do nothing. What do you do? | The employer is now on notice and must look into it. Tell her it will be as discreet as the process allows, that retaliation is prohibited, and then act. Never promise complete confidentiality. | |
| 10 | During a union organizing campaign, what can supervisors say, and what can they not? | They may share views and facts, such as what dues cost and that a union cannot guarantee a result. They may not threaten, question employees about cards or votes, promise benefits for a no vote, or watch union activity. | |
| 11 | Our company has 17 employees. Which federal discrimination laws cover us? | Title VII and the ADA from 15 employees, the ADEA from 20, so the age law does not reach this employer federally. A strong answer adds that state and local laws can reach smaller employers. | |
| 12 | A payroll administrator moved to marketing 10 weeks ago and still has full payroll access. What failed, and what do you put in place? | Deprovisioning. Access should change on the transfer date with the role, under role-based access and least privilege, with regular access reviews to catch what slips through. | |

Source: https://credentialpress.com/guides/phr-interview-questions
