# SHRM-CP interview scorecard

Candidate: ______  Interviewer: ______  Date: ______

| # | Question | Listen for | Score 1 to 4 |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | A vice president tells staff to use their vacation, then turns down every request from his own team. How do you raise it with him? | Authenticity: his words and his decisions point in opposite directions, and the team has noticed. A strong answer raises it with him privately, with the specific pattern and its effect on trust, and offers a way through, such as planning cover so leave can be taken. | |
| 2 | A hiring manager wants a college degree for warehouse jobs that do not need one. What do you tell her? | Disparate impact: a neutral requirement that screens out a protected group at a far greater rate breaks Title VII unless it is job related and consistent with business necessity. A strong answer checks the applicant data and sets requirements from a job analysis. | |
| 3 | At an HR association dinner, a competitor's HR manager suggests both firms hold starting pay and stop recruiting each other's staff. What do you do? | End the conversation at once, share no pay data, and report it to counsel. Federal antitrust agencies treat wage-fixing and no-poach agreements between employers as violations, and an informal agreement is still an agreement. | |
| 4 | In an investigation interview, a witness says the supervisor "did his usual thing." What is your next question? | A probing question in the witness's own words, such as what she means by his usual thing. No leading questions. A strong answer adds that the finding will rest on the weight of the evidence, not on an admission or a count of witnesses. | |
| 5 | Turnover in one warehouse has risen sharply this year. How would you find out why? | Turnover against average headcount, split into voluntary and involuntary, then by team, tenure and manager. Exit and stay interviews, the cost of the turnover, and a plan with a measure the leadership team agrees to. | |
| 6 | How would you show a leadership team that a safety program is worth its cost? | Return on investment and payback built from the program's cost and savings that finance agrees with, the assumptions stated, and the business result the program supports, not only the HR activity. | |
| 7 | An employee's pay sits well below the midpoint of her grade. What do you look at before recommending a raise? | Her compa-ratio and range penetration, her performance and time in the job, what peers in the grade earn, how the market has moved, and the budget. Then a recommendation the manager can explain to her. | |
| 8 | A manager rates an analyst top marks on every dimension because of one impressive project. What do you do? | The halo effect. Each dimension rated against its standard and the record, such as attendance, with rater training and calibration across managers so one result does not carry the whole review. | |
| 9 | A 40-person startup wants better benefits than it can buy on its own. What would you put to the founders? | A professional employer organization, with co-employment explained: the PEO becomes an employer of record for payroll, tax reporting and benefits while the startup directs the work. A strong answer compares it with an ASO arrangement and says what control the founders give up. | |
| 10 | A grievance has reached an impasse. How do you choose between mediation and arbitration? | Mediation leaves the outcome with the parties. Nonbinding arbitration gives an advisory decision either side can reject. Binding arbitration is final. The choice trades control over the outcome against certainty of getting one, inside whatever the contract requires. | |
| 11 | An employee falls from a platform and is admitted to hospital overnight. What does HR do in the first day? | Care for the employee first. Report the in-patient hospitalization to OSHA within 24 hours, record it on the OSHA 300 log if the employer keeps one, investigate the cause, and make sure nobody is punished for raising the hazard. | |

Source: https://credentialpress.com/guides/shrm-cp-interview-questions
